Ratification’s Challenge: The Good News
The recent ratification of Amendment 14F by greater than a 2/3 majority of presbyteries reflects a powerful statement by the Presbyterian Church (USA) and its members. Added to the the changes in ordination and marriage equality, this ratified revisionÂ of the description of marriage – erases the constitutional barriers to inclusion based on gender and sexual identity in the denomination.
It is almost a moment too great to contemplate.Â Forty years and lifetimes ofÂ prayerÂ and sacrifice; decades of marginalization met with steadfast resistance; the resulting study of the bible and texts;Â the lifting up of God’s glorious diversity in one another; and the refusal to let others define us: these reflect only part of the story of prophetic and courageous acts of justice and love by this denomination’s members. We have truly made the way clear for the PC(USA) and others to follow in the evangelism that is now ours to share.
But we are not done.
Long before there existed any progressive movement or the advances that have been achieved, the treatment of our sisters and brothers who identified as queer — wasÂ wrong, terribly wrong. And, recentÂ legislation did not make us somehow, suddenly “right.”
The changes we are witnessing have to be viewed asÂ the acknowledgment that for years our and other communities of faith have been wrong, sinfully wrong in the way our sisters and brothers who identify as Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender, Queer+ have been unwelcome. The charges of inhospitality carry a heavy price in the sacred texts, and our queer community has borne the brunt of exclusion and the residual violence – simply because others refused to see what the majority of folks have now come to know.
While one could make the argument that these changes and levels of acceptance and understanding take time, and they would be correct to do so — I would counter that the levels of loveÂ and hospitality, supplanted by fear and judgment is where the original error exists, not in who God created us to be.
Our LGBTQ+ sisters and brothers have brought about more than a change in the constitution of the PC(USA), our sisters and brothers are bringing about a change in the way we love and accept one another. These forty years have been forty years of bringing the Good News to resoundingÂ levels that can now be heard by more people than ever before.
The question is: Is the churchÂ up to thisÂ new thing God is doing?
To be heard, institutions such as the PC(USA) cannot simply rely on legislative changes or practices to point to catharsis. Years of teachings and practices that have caused so much pain, suffering and contributed to the violence of so many — have to be directly addressed at the highest of levels. It is such anÂ acknowledgment of the wrongs and harms done as a result of the past positions of the denomination that first must be spokenÂ — before the new welcoming to those who have been shunned can be heard.
This ancient practice ofÂ amends and admission of wrongs done is now more critical than ever before. Any prospect forÂ reconciliation that lay ahead will depend upon it, for this is the path that must be followed if we are to eliminate fear and judgment with love and hospitality.
It is a time to admit and acknowledge that the Love of God and one another has been renewedÂ in ways by the Presbyterian Church (USA) that was long-lost and has now been found. A time to welcome, as never before!
Such an admission and invitation, spoken with courage and humility, will open our doors more widely than we could ever imagine. It will change the way theÂ church andÂ its teachings and practices have been misusedÂ to harm others for way too long.
This is what the ratification of 14FÂ now challenges us to do.
And, my friends, this is the Good News. Good News for all.
~ Ray Bagnuolo
Submitted on 2015/05/19 at 3:58 pm
I agree with you Ray. This is very well written. I have had my eye on much of the PCUSA online media these days and I find very little or NO mention of this historic decision. It makes me wonder if they are not proud of passing this Amendment. Itâ€™s as though the denomination continues to hide it under the rug and keep us still in the closet.